2025 NFL All-Draft Team: Barron, Milroe Headline Star-Studded Team

The dust has officially settled on the 2025 NFL Draft, but the discussion is not yet over. Just like Todd McShay’s annual All-Satellite Team and Mel Kiper’s annual draft grades, an annual tradition of my draft coverage here at FFSN is creating my All-Draft team.

If you have not yet listened to last week’s episode of The Draft Dynasty Podcast, make sure you do so below. On that show, Jeremy and I created our All-22 All-Draft teams for 2025. You won’t want to miss it!

This year, we are creating two distinct teams. If you have seen my teams in years past, you are probably familiar with my by-round approach. I choose my favorite selection from each round and then choose three other selections I like as “bench” options for that round. I do it for all seven rounds as well as undrafted free agency. For the third year in a row, however, we will be releasing another team which fills out a starting 11 for both offense and defense. To fill out that roster, I will select three players from each round as well as one undrafted free agent.

Here are the official ground rules for the by-round format created back in 2017:

• Simply choose your favorite four or five players (or fits) taken in each round of the draft.
• From those lists of four or five players, choose one that you like slightly above the rest. The others are your “bench” options.
• You cannot be too obvious with your first pick. In other words, Joe Burrow was not allowed back in 2020, and Penei Sewell and Trevor Lawrence were not allowed in 2021. So this year, no Caleb Williams or Marvin Harrison, Jr. Be reasonable with it. Avoid players who were selected or, in some cases, projected to go in the top 5 picks of the draft.

For reference, here are my teams from the last two years.

2023

Round 1- Nolan Smith — EDGE — Georgia
Bench: Will McDonald IV (EDGE), Mazi Smith (NT), Darnell Wright, Jaxon Smith-Njigba (WR)
Round 2- Joey Porter, Jr. — CB — Penn State
Bench: Cody Mauch (OL), Sam LaPorta (TE), DJ Turner (CB), Gervon Dexter (DT)
Round 3- Sydney Brown — S — Illinois
Bench: Darnell Washington (TE), Tyjae Spears (RB), Trenton Simpson (ILB), Dorian Williams (ILB)
Round 4- Clark Phillips III — CB — Utah
Bench: Adetomiwa Adebawore (EDGE), Jake Andrews (C), Chandler Zavala (G), Aidan O’Connell (QB)
Round 5- Chase Brown — RB — Illinois
Bench: Israel Abanikanda (RB), Darius Rush (CB), Yasir Abdullah (ILB), Olusegun Oluwatimi (C)
Round 6- JL Skinner — S — Boise State
Bench: Luke Wypler (C), Parker Washington (WR/RB), Jarrick Bernard-Converse (CB), Andrei Iosivas (WR)
Round 7- Andrew Vorhees — G — USC
Bench: Zack Kuntz (TE), Lew Nichols III (RB), DeWayne McBride (RB), Cory Trice (CB)
UDFA- Bryce Ford-Wheaton — WR — West Virginia
Bench: Steven Gilmore (CB), Ben VanSumeren (ILB), Joey Fisher (OT), Trevor Nowaske (ILB)

2024

Round 1- Quinyon Mitchell | CB | Toledo
Bench: Troy Fautanu (OL), Graham Barton (G), Teliese Fuaga (OT), Dallas Turner (EDGE)
Round 2- Braden Fiske | DT | Florida State
Bench: Keon Coleman (WR), Mike Sainristill (CB), Zach Frazier (C), Ladd McConkey (WR)
Round 3- Junior Colson | ILB | Michigan
Bench: Zak Zinter (G), Malachi Corley (WR), Jonah Elliss (EDGE), Blake Corum (RB)
Round 4- Jaylen Wright | RB | Tennessee
Bench: Malik Mustapha (S), Will Shipley (RB), Jaden Hicks (S), Mason McCormick (OL)
Round 5- Sedrick Van Pran | C | Georgia
Bench: Jeremiah Trotter, Jr. (ILB), Ainias Smith (WR), Quan’tez Stiggers (CB), Mohamed Kamara (EDGE)
Round 6- Nathaniel Watson | ILB | Mississippi State
Bench: Christian Mahogany (G), Malik Washington (WR), Marcellas Dial (CB), Kimani Vidal (RB)
Round 7- Jaheim Bell | TE | Florida State
Bench: Travis Clayton (OT), M.J. Devonshire (CB), Jaylen Harrell (EDGE), Brenden Rice (WR)
UDFA- Blake Watson | RB | Memphis
Bench: Beanie Bishop (CB), Shon Stephens (CB), Ryan Rehkow (P), Drake Nugent (C)

Now that you have the idea, let’s take a look at my official all-draft team for 2025.

2025 All-Draft Team (Traditional By-Round Format)

Round 1- Jahdae Barron | CB | Texas
Bench: Jihaad Campbell (ILB), Malaki Starks (S), Kenneth Grant (DT), Derrick Harmon (DT)
Round 2- Will Johnson | CB | Michigan
Bench: Mike Green (EDGE), Nick Emmanwori (S), Tate Ratledge (G), Luther Burden III (WR)
Round 3- Jalen Milroe | QB | Alabama
Bench: Darius Alexander (DT), Jared Wilson (C), Shavon Revel, Jr. (CB), Nohl Williams (CB)
Round 4- Ty Robinson | DT | Nebraska
Bench: Dont’e Thornton (WR), Jack Kiser (ILB), Kyle Kennard (EDGE), Malachi Moore (S)
Round 5- DJ Giddens | RB | Kansas State
Bench: Rylie Mills (DT), Shedeur Sanders (QB), Smael Mondon, Jr. (ILB), Jaydon Blue (RB)
Round 6- Cameron Williams | OT | Texas
Bench: Kyle McCord (QB), Devin Neal (RB), Will Howard (QB), Jaylen Reed (S)
Round 7- Brashard Smith | RB | SMU
Bench: Fadil Diggs (EDGE), Tez Johnson (WR), Damien Martinez (RB), LeQuint Allen (RB)
UDFA- Xavier Restrepo | WR | Miami
Bench: Donovan Edwards (RB), Desmond Watson (DT), Seth McLaughlin (C), Leif Fautanu (C)

Which player was your favorite selection on this year’s team? What would your team be? Be sure to play along by adding your team, as well as your reaction to mine, in the comment section below!