Have the Steelers done enough on defense this offseason to address their “Baltimore problem?”
Steelers’ defensive coordinator Teryl Austin made an interesting comment to reporters after one of last week’s mini-camp practices. When asked about the struggles of his unit down the stretch last season, when Pittsburgh surrendered an average of 27.5 points over their final five games, all of which were losses, Austin said:
“We had a Baltimore problem last year. There’s no way to get around it. They ran the ball down our throats, and we have to fix that if we want to contend in this division.”
The fact that Austin singled out the Ravens in a question that addressed a broader topic says a lot about Pittsburgh’s off-season focus. Two of those five losses were to Baltimore, and in those games the Steelers gave up 519 combined rushing yards, including an astounding 299 in their Wild Card playoff defeat. No team is built to withstand that kind of gouging at the hands of an opposing rushing attack, much less one that prides itself on stopping the run like the Steelers. To put it bluntly, those Baltimore losses were embarrassing, not simply because the Steelers were outscored by 31 points but because they were physically dominated.
Austin’s comment was consistent with the team’s focus this off-season on preventing a repeat of that Baltimore dominance in 2025. Have the Steelers done enough on defense to accomplish this? We’ll see. But they’ve certainly made a concerted effort. Here’s a look by position group at how Pittsburgh has addressed its “Baltimore problem.”
Defensive Line
The most obvious move has been the addition of first-round draft pick Derrick Harmon, whom the Steelers selected 21st overall out of Oregon. Harmon is 6’5-312-pounds and has the size to hold up against a physical Baltimore offensive line. But he plays with the explosiveness of a much smaller man. Harmon’s best traits are his hand usage and his ability to shed blocks. He rarely stays blocked for long, which will be refreshing after watching several of the team’s defensive linemen stick to blocks last season as though they were magnetized. Harmon will start immediately in Pittsburgh’s base 3-4, and will rotate with Cam Heyward and Keeanu Benton when they play their 2-4-5 sub-package. His presence should help stabilize a unit that was pushed around far too easily by the Ravens last season.
Fifth-round pick Yahya Black, from Iowa, could see time as a situational run-stopper as well. You have to believe Black was drafted with the Ravens in mind. At 6’6-336 pounds, he’s a massive human being who will, if nothing else, clog up space in the A and B gaps. Black plays too high at present and will have to work on lowering his pad level to command the double teams the Steelers would like him to. But with some seasoning, he could be provide much-needed beef to combat Derrick Henry and Company.
Finally, one of the under-the-radar signings of the off-season was Daniel Ekuale, a 6’3-300-pound veteran who started 16 games in New England last season. Ekuale is not a sexy name, and he won’t make many splash plays. But he provides valuable experience and should be an upgrade over depth pieces from last season like Montravius Adams and Dean Lowry.
The Steelers got bigger, younger and deeper on the defensive line this off-season. That should pay dividends in combating the Ravens.
Edge
T.J. Watt did not attend mini-camp, and may hold out, or hold in, or do whatever veterans do these days when they don’t want to get injured while negotiating a new contract. I’ll go on the record in saying the Steelers will get a deal done with him over the summer, and when we kick off in September he will look and play like T.J. Watt.
Elsewhere, the only change to this group is the addition of fourth-round pick Jack Sawyer, a high-energy, high-motor edge from Ohio State. Sawyer may not be a major impact player this season, but his presence, as well as that of Nick Herbig, could be significant. The Steelers had just two total sacks in their two losses to Baltimore last season, and Watt appeared to wear down late in the year. If Sawyer and Herbig can command enough reps to keep Watt and Alex Highsmith fresh, Watt’s production, and the production of the group as a whole, should rise.
Linebacker
One veteran run-thumper, Elandon Roberts, left in free agency, while another, former Raven Malik Harrison, was signed. Otherwise, this unit returns intact. That is significant, considering the group was overhauled last season and the new pieces took time to gel.
Patrick Queen should be more comfortable with Austin’s defense this year, and Payton Wilson should take a leap in his second season. Harrison should be valuable as a younger, more athletic version of Roberts. The most significant addition will be the return of Cole Holcomb, who played solid football for the Steelers in 2023 before missing all of last season with a knee injury. If Holcomb is back to form, this unit will be well-suited to match up with Baltimore. It will have a combination of thumpers to combat the inside run and athletes to run down plays in the alley. It may, when all is said and done, be Pittsburgh’s best linebacking corps in years.
Secondary
One player who turned heads at last week’s mini-camp was free agent signee Juan Thornhill. The veteran safety was used in a variety of roles and gave the Steelers the ability to make extensive use of their three-safety package. Having Thornhill, Minkah Fitzpatrick and DeShon Elliott on the field together could be a great way to combat Baltimore. The Ravens feasted in the run game last season when Beanie Bishop was on the field for Pittsburgh as a nickel corner. Baltimore ran right at Bishop and made the 5’9-180-pound rookie fight off blocks and tackle Henry. That worked decidedly to Baltimore’s advantage.
Thornhill is bigger (6’0-205) and stronger than Bishop and will hold up much better against the run. He may not be as accomplished in coverage, but he shouldn’t be considered a liability. And, with Fitzpatrick and Elliott on the field, as well as starting corners Joey Porter Jr. and Darius Slay, he’ll have plenty of help. If Pittsburgh wants their best defenders in the lineup when Baltimore goes 11-personnel, the three-safety nickel package could be the way to go.
Overall
The Steelers seem much better positioned to defend Baltimore’s offense than they were a year ago. They are bigger and stronger on the defensive line, deeper at edge and at linebacker, and better suited to match up with Baltimore in the secondary. At worst, the Steelers should not get trampled by Baltimore’s run game the way they did late last season. At best, they may now have the pieces to stymie the Ravens in their quest to take back the AFC North division title.
Before reading the article I said hell no. After reading the article I still think the answer is no. They were so easily handled by Baltimore last season they barely had to activate Lamar. So while I agree they should be more than a small speed-bump for the Ravens run game, untill they can slow the run AND pressure Lamar the Ravens will continue to dominate them.
I think if you look at the games they were three very different games. The first one was really about the Henry fumble on the first drive. It made Harbaugh impatient and the moved away from the and never really got back to it. Henry had 4-11 in the first quarter and 6-41 in the second (with a 31-yard run). He only had 5 carries in the second half all in the third quarter. Then you couple that with them not running Jackson either.
They scored early so Harbaugh styed patient and mixed run and pass really well. Also the Steelers started slow (as usual) and put no pressure on them.
Correct. The only reason the first game was close is they were not running. They will continue to run at this D intill they show they can stop or slow it down. I sure wouldn’t throw at this D if I’m them.
That Henry fumble in the first game isn’t much different from the Wilson fumble in the second game. If Wilson doesn’t fumble, and the steelers score there and the Steelers score and go up 14-7, it may have been a different game. The only one I think was a true blowout was the playoff game, at which time the wheels had come off for PIT. I may be wrong, but I don’t think the difference between the two teams is as big as some do.
That’s great to hear from you coach!
I accept that I may be overly pessimistic, but I live in Baltimore so I have a very raw nerve regarding that team.
My condolences! (Kidding… kind of).
I agree with you on the spread. I think a lot of people downplay the talent that the Steelers have due to the mediocre to poor play they have had at QB. This team looks a whole lot better with the 12th best QB in league.
It should be somewhat better. The big thing is are they better when 97 is off the field. I am hopeful that adding Harmon and Black is better than Ogunjobi. Everything else is mostly the same. I guess you could add in Leal as a guy that didn’t play in 2024 but I am not very high on him especially in that role.
If Sawyer is a player that will help as well because Herbig is really just a pass rusher and isn’t really going to set an edge when he is in.
Hopefully, they return to the scheme that worked in the first Ravens games last year and not the Playoff scheme.
Coach – the main problem that the Steelers had against the run last year was that they couldn’t stop the run against 11 personnel (when we trotted out the nickel package). This showed up first against Indy and the league eventually figured it out.
Is the only change this year (against 11 personnel) that they’ve replaced Ogunjobi and Bishop with Harmon and Thornhill in nickel? How do other teams attack this situation?
Bishop got mauled against the run last year. They eventually replaced him with Sutton, and he didn’t fare much better. Thornhill is a huge upgrade from those two. I’m hoping Harmon is a similar upgrade over Ogunjobi.
PIT’s interest in Jalen Ramsey is interesting. If they acquire Ramsey (a longshot, IMO, but you never know), they can match up man-to-man across the field with BAL, which will allow them to get an extra safety into the box to defend the run. That’s how you do it when BAL goes 11 personnel. You play cover-1, go +1 in the box and hope your coverage holds up.
The three-safety package becomes your change-up vs. 11-p.
Ramsey would have to bend on his current desired salary, Miami does not want to split salary or release him, at present. Miami is an odd organization, lately.
I don’t know…I think this was slight of hand by a middling coach with almost no creativity. Austin’s defense had a lot more than a problem with just one team. The final stretch of games is as much on the defense as the qb play.
Quite simply, they got figured out and had no answers. They also might have been gassed. I remember Troy Polamalu talked about Tomlin’s first season taking over and how hard he rode them in camp to kind of make the point that he wasn’t Cowher. Troy said that definitely had an effect on them later in the year and in the playoffs against NE. More injuries and exhaustion. The next year camp wasn’t as strenuous and the team endures well all the way to the SB. (And it’s not like last year was the first year we witnessed the wheels come off the team at the end of the season. Far from it.)
Then, last year, we hear about Wilson, for some stupid reason, being required to push a sled and how “intense” the Steelers camp was. And Watt gets injured late and the defense just can’t compete by season’s end. It sounds to me like someone forgot the lesson they learned 18 years ago with a similar but much worse result. (Probably because this team isn’t as talented as that one was and the DC is no where near HOF level so it has no margin for error when it comes to foolishness.)
Have they added enough talent to beat Baltimore? They might have always had it- it wasn’t long ago that the Steelers D was the bane of their offense. An offense led by Kenny Pickett could repeatedly beat them because they couldn’t score. I think the better question is have the coaches done enough reformation in their methods to prevent yet another late season collapse against whomever they are facing?
I know I, for one, will struggle to get as excited about this team as I might have in the past based on their first ten or eleven games. I’ve seen the bottom fall out too many times. And when a coach moves the shells and obfuscates the larger issue at hand like he did here- it definitely doesn’t fill me with much confidence that enough changes will be made.
a true Pittsburgh Steelers fan, since the 70’s Yes! the Steelers defense shuold be much better in stopping Lamar Jackson and Derrick Henry but Steelers Omar Khan still needs to draft a replacement player for Cameron Heyward in the draft
Ed is that not to be Derrick Harmon?